Helping to shape the future litigation system

08 November 2013 - No comments »

EPO President Benoît BattistelliOn 25 and 26 October the European Patent Academy‘s European Judges Forum was held at Venice International University on the island of San Servolo. This forum, launched in 2005 and organised in co-operation with the Intellectual Property Judges Association (IPJA) and the European Patent Lawyers Association (EPLAW), brings together a large number of judges and lawyers specialising in patent litigation from the various EPO member states. This year’s forum was attended by 32 judges from 15 different countries and 27 lawyers from 12 different countries. The Venice Forum focuses on a mix of substantive and procedural issues, including a mock trial followed by group work. Its unique, informal and interactive setting, the intensive off-the-record discussions, and the expertise and commitment of the participants, allow judges and lawyers from different jurisdictions to develop a better and common understanding of issues of patent law and litigation. In my opinion, this forum makes a big contribution to the quality, consistency and predictability of jurisprudence across Europe.

This year’s forum addressed substantive law issues such as second medical use claims and the related case law of EPO boards of appeal and of national courts, as well as the relationship between standards and patent law, and the role of competition law in litigation involving standards-essential patents. Not surprisingly, a significant part of this year’s discussions and work was devoted to issues surrounding the unitary patent and the Unified Patent Court. The discussions on the court’s draft rules of procedure and several hot topics such as the criteria to be applied by judges for granting injunctions, or their discretion over bifurcation of infringement and invalidity actions, were especially intensive and productive. The mock trial in particular, which included the bifurcation issue, demonstrated that judges and lawyers from across Europe are able to develop common views on such topics, despite their different national judicial traditions and concepts. It also showed that the fears of “forum-shopping” voiced by certain industry representatives during the public consultation on the court’s draft rules of procedure do not seem really justified.

It is likely that the unitary patent and the Unified Patent Court will continue to be discussed at the Venice Forum in the coming years. Given the experience of these seasoned practitioners, and their commitment to a soundly functioning future litigation system, I am very confident that they will provide users with a solid and balanced legal framework that will be entirely fit for purpose. As I have said before, the creation of a high-quality centralised court system is one of the missing links in Europe’s patent system, and fundamental to the success of the unitary patent, as it will help to build user confidence.

Meanwhile, at national level, the ratification process was finalised in Austria during the summer, and seems well advanced in the UK, France and Belgium.

For its part, the EPO, which has observer status on the preparatory committee working to set up the Unified Patent Court, is committed to doing all it can to support this work. The European Patent Academy, which has a wealth of experience in training patent judges through study visits, internships, conferences and seminars such as the Venice Forum, will redouble its efforts in this regard.

Benoît Battistelli

  • Share this post:

Older posts

Patent information stays high on the agenda

Last week, I attended the EPO Patent Information Conference, hosted this year by the city of Bologna, which, as an industrial, academic and cultural centre that has nurtured so many innovative minds, was the perfect location for a headline conference dealing with the dissemination of technical knowledge. This year’s event drew some 400 patent information […]

The EPO at 40 – a European and technical success

Last week, on 17 October, the EPO marked the 40th anniversary of the signing of the European Patent Convention, which took place in Munich on 5 October 1973. I had the pleasure of welcoming many guests from all over the world, in particular from Europe, the US and Asia. Among those attending the events organised […]

Measuring IP’s economic benefits

Last week in Brussels, at a press conference with Commissioner Michel Barnier and OHIM President António Campinos, I had the pleasure of presenting an EPO/OHIM joint study on the economic impact of intellectual property rights (IPR) in the EU. The study has a pioneering significance. Although some research has already been done on specific IP […]

Dynamic trends in the global patent system

At this year’s WIPO Assemblies, which began last week in Geneva, I had the opportunity to meet many heads of IP offices. My immediate impression was of a widespread determination to modernise national frameworks and ensure that innovation policy and the patent system are at the top of national agendas. In most cases, these plans […]

Moving patent information up the agenda

This week in Munich I met the Board of the Patent Documentation Group, a long-established association of companies seeking to promote the effective use of patent information. We talked in depth about improvements, current projects and outstanding issues in this key area. Opportunities for such exchanges are limited, as most user groups tend to focus […]

Patentability: maintaining the balance

New IP challenges arise as new technologies emerge from R&D activities. This has been a pivotal issue for the patent system throughout its history, with the continual extension of its scope due to technical progress. In Europe, the mechanisms established 40 years ago with the signing of the European Patent Convention  have proved to be […]

First half of 2013 – a preliminary assessment

The end of the summer break is usually a good time to review the first half of the year and see if any trends are already apparent from the facts and figures available. So this could be a good opportunity to update you on our activities, even if some of the data is still provisional. […]

A new building in The Hague

As an organisation requiring top performance from its staff, the EPO is committed to provide a working environment that meets the highest international standards. A central aspect of this concerns the buildings in which staff carry out their daily tasks. The EPO’s building policy has to cater for five sites of very different size, in […]

Croatia’s EU accession – good news for Europe

Today, Croatia joined the European Union as its 28th full member. It has already been a member of the European Patent Organisation since 1 January 2008, playing a very active role in both institutional matters and our co-operation activities. Last year in Zagreb, the Croatian IP office and the EPO co-hosted an important European Patent […]